Regional Monthly Seminar Series
Rethinking Childhood in the Twenty-First Century
How Imagination Aids Childhood Coping:
Ethnographic, Experimental and Clinical Evidence


Rutgers University - Camden
October 24, 2002

Cindy Dell Clark, PhD
Assistant Professor of Human Development and Family Studies
Pennsylvania State University;
CCCS Associate and Fellow, Rutgers University-Camden

email: cdc9@psu.edu

Cindy Dell Clark's book, In Sickness and in Play: Children Coping with Chronic Illness will be published by the Rutgers University Press in 2003, as part of its series in Childhood Studies. The book reports on an ethnographic study of 5-to-8 year old children suffering from severe asthma or diabetes. In this study, children's own views of illness were given voice, through child-centered interviewing methods. Play and imagination emerged from the research as an important aspect of how children coped with illness.

As Clark described, coping with play and imagination (called "imaginal coping") has been a scant subject in past clinical and experimental research. Based on Clark's ethnographic investigation, it was clear that young illness sufferers used imagination to cope, in day-to-day life. First, children used toys, blankets, or even decorated bed sheets as transitional objects, objects which reassured them about their security and safety amidst illness. Adults were not always aware of the emotional value of transitional objects. A kindergartner recalled that when hospitalized at age three, nurses deprived her of her trusted stuffed tiger, which the nurses mistakenly felt was Intimidating rather than protective. In other cases, parents were sensitive, aware and supportive of children's use of toys as transitional objects, making sure that trusted toys were available.

Another form of imaginal coping concerned rituals practiced along with treatment, such as when administering medication by injection (in diabetes) or by a machine-nebulizer (in asthma). Such rituals included games, which were co-constructed between child and family members. One boy with diabetes sang the refrain from Handel's Hallelujah chorus upon receiving each insulin injection. Rituals were also co-constructed among young illness sufferers who attended summer camp together. At asthma camp, a group of kids playfully made "music" using as instruments the spacers meant to be attached to inhalers - as they waited in line for medications at camp.

Imaginal coping, as a theoretical construct, is defined as the use of imagination to transform and reframe the hardships of illness. Such coping is advantageous to chronically ill children, for whom selfhood does not flow harmoniously in line with the usual norms - due to exceptionalizing experiences such as dietary restrictions or frightening symptoms. Imaginal coping depends on the flexibility to remake meanings, as individuals manipulate cultural symbols and materials in social concert, whether in a family context or at summer camp.

In Clark's presentation, she suggested that imaginal coping may hold further promise as an intervention to promote adherence to treatment in asthma. Clark described a controlled experimental test being conducted in conjunction with Penn State Hershey Medical Center and Crozer Chester Medical Center, of whether popular fantasy characters (Spiderman or Tweety) might be incorporated into asthma treatment to enhance adherence to treatment.


Seminar Pictures

First CCCS Regional Childhood Studies Seminar lecture
was held on Thursday, Oct 24th, 2002
Dr. Jane Siegel (Criminal Justice) chatting with
our guest speaker from Penn State, Dr. Cindy Dell Clark
Looks like Drs. Stuart Charme and Bill Whitlow
are engaged in a serious conversation
Dr. Myra Bluebond-Langner
Director, CCCS
Center Staff, Amy DeCicco and Lori Mariano always working hard

Selected Publications:

Clark, Cindy Dell. In Sickness and in Play: Children Coping with Chronic Illness. Rutgers University Press [forthcoming]

1995. (1998 Paperback.) Flights of Fancy, Leaps of Faith: Children's Myths in Contemporary America. University of Chicago Press. Click here to read segments from this book and listen to an interview with Cindy Dell Clark.

1998. "Humor and Humorous Play in Chronic Illness," in Children and Youth: A Universal Odyssey (A. Richardson, ed.), Kanita Learning Company.

1998. "Childhood Imagination in the Face of Chronic Illness," in Believed In Imaginings (T. Sarbin and J. DeRivera, eds.), American Psychological Association.

1998. "Play," Review chapter (with Peggy Miller) Encyclopedia of Mental Health. Academic Press.



Other Presentations:

March 1999. Invited talk: "Child-centered Research: An Overview," at Harvard Medical School, Dept. of Social Medicine.

August 2000. "Illness as Visual Metaphor: Visual Props in a Study of Childhood Chronic Illness" to American Sociological Association annual meeting, Washington, D.C.


Last updated March 9, 2003